- Home
- Resources
- Laws & regulations
- Summary of appeals received by the Competition Appeal Board (CAB)
- Appeals 2023
Appeals 2023
Appeals received by the Competition Appeal Board (CAB) in 2023.
Last updated 22 October 2025
Appeals 2023
Appeal Number: 1/2023
Appeal Title: Notice of Appeal by CNL Logistics Solutions Pte Ltd and Gilmon Transportation & Warehouse Pte Ltd on CCCS Infringement Decision in relation to price fixing by warehouse operators at Keppel Distripark
Date Received: 16 January 2023
CAB's Decision: Completed [PDF, 814 KB]
Appeal Number: 1/2023
Appellants: CNL Logistics Solutions Pte Ltd and Gilmon Transportation & Warehouse Pte Ltd
Date Received: Notice of Appeal received on 16 January 2023
Summary of CCCS Decision that Appeal Relates:
Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore (“CCCS”) issued an ID against four undertakings~ (collectively, the “Parties”) for contravening section 34 of the Competition Act (Cap.50B) (the “Act”) by engaging in price fixing conduct by imposing in a coordinated manner an additional charge known as “FTZ Surcharge” for warehouse services at Keppel Distripark. CCCS imposed financial penalties totalling S$2,799,138 on the Parties for the infringement.
The 4 undertakings are:
(a) CNL Logistics Solutions Pte Ltd (“CNL”)
(b) Gilmon Transportation & Warehouse Pte Ltd (“Gilmon”)
(c) Penanshin (PSA KD) Pte Ltd (“Penanshin”); and
(d) Mac-Nels (KD) Terminal Pte Ltd (“Mac-Nels”)
Read the full text of the Infringement Decision
Relief Sought by Appellants:
Liability and the quantum of the financial penalty imposed
Appeal Number: 2/2023
Appeal Title: Notice of Appeal by Mac-Nels (KD) Terminal Pte Ltd on CCCS Infringement Decision in relation to price fixing by warehouse operators at Keppel Distripark
Date Received: 17 January 2023
CAB's Decision: In Progress
Appeal Number: 2/2023
Appellant: Mac-Nels (KD) Terminal Pte Ltd
Date Received: Notice of Appeal received on 17 January 2023
Summary of CCCS Decision that Appeal Relates:
Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore (“CCCS”) issued an ID against four undertakings~ (collectively, the “Parties”) for contravening section 34 of the Competition Act (Cap.50B) (the “Act”) by engaging in price fixing conduct by imposing in a coordinated manner an additional charge known as “FTZ Surcharge” for warehouse services at Keppel Distripark. CCCS imposed financial penalties totalling S$2,799,138 on the Parties for the infringement.
The 4 undertakings are:
(a) CNL Logistics Solutions Pte Ltd (“CNL”)
(b) Gilmon Transportation & Warehouse Pte Ltd (“Gilmon”)
(c) Penanshin (PSA KD) Pte Ltd (“Penanshin”); and
(d) Mac-Nels (KD) Terminal Pte Ltd (“Mac-Nels”)
Read the full text of the Infringement Decision
Relief Sought by Appellant:
Quantum of the financial penalty imposed